The recent decision of the Full Bench of the South Australian Employment Tribunal in Richards v Little Company of Mary Health Care [2018] SAET 186 concerned a self-represented litigant, and whether the Deputy President who heard the initial hearing in the matter satisfied his duty to the self-represented litigant.

The Appellant, who was the Applicant in the initial hearing, was largely self-represented before the Deputy President. She, in the Appeal before the Full Bench (where she was also self-represented), asserted that the Deputy President did not fulfil his duty to her as a self-represented litigant.

The Full Bench noted that during the initial hearing His Honour granted multiple adjournments to the Appellant in order to assist her in putting her case. Further, the Full Bench noted that His Honour provided assistance to the Appellant on multiple occasions during the hearing by way of explaining processes and procedures that she was required to follow, as well as intervening in the proceedings in order to assist the Appellant.

The Full Bench concluded that His Honour “maintained impartiality and neutrality throughout the proceedings”, and as such rejected the Appellant’s argument that His Honour failed in his duty towards her as a self-represented litigant.

President Justice Dolphin helpfully set out nine principles that Tribunal members should follow when dealing with self-represented litigants. These principles are:

  1. The paramount duty is to ensure a fair trial, in accordance with law, for all parties.
  2. A self-represented litigant is to be assisted so as to balance any disadvantage that person may suffer from the lack of representation. An assessment is to be made as to the degree of assistance required.
  3. In redressing any imbalance, the other party(s) to the litigation are not to be disadvantaged.
  4. To ensure procedural fairness, necessary and appropriate steps should be taken to explain the relevant processes and procedures to the self-represented litigant.
  5. The duty to provide procedural fairness does not extend to providing advice as to how the self-represented litigant should exercise his or her rights.
  6. The duty to provide procedural fairness does not extend to conducting the self-represented litigant’s case for them.
  7. Assistance to the self-represented litigant may be in the form of necessary intervention, during the proceedings, to ensure a fair trial.
  8. The self-represented litigant may be reprimanded for unreasonable behaviour.
  9. Impartially and neutrality are to be maintained at all times; the touchstone is fairness.

When people are dealing with self-represented litigants at the Tribunal, we suggest that they have these principles in mind in order to assist the Tribunal in meeting their obligations to the self-represented litigant.

If you would like more information in relation to duties towards self-represented litigants, please contact us for advice and assistance.

This communication provides general information which is current as at the time of production. The information contained in this communication does not constitute advice and should not be relied upon as such. Professional advice should be sought prior to any action being taken in reliance on any of the information. Should you wish to discuss any matter raised in this article, or what it means for you, your business or your clients' businesses, please feel free to contact us.

Related Articles

View All News
June 19, 2024 “Combination” Clarity on Causation or Query on “Consequential”
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
April 18, 2024 2025 Edition of Best Lawyers: Celebrating Our Leaders and a Rising Star
Firm News Corporate & Commercial Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety + 6
April 02, 2024 Introducing DW Fox Tucker Lawyers Newest Director
Firm News Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
December 20, 2023 Seriously Injured Workers and the Obligation of Mutuality
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
November 28, 2023 Payroll Tax and Medical Practices: An Update and Warning to Others
Tax Health & Aged Care Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety
October 19, 2023 Bridging the Gap: New Director Enhances Workers Compensation Practice
Firm News Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
September 27, 2023 Workers Compensation in South Australia: Has Malinauskas Kicked an Own Goal?
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
September 15, 2023 Payroll Tax and Medical Practices
Tax Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Health & Aged Care
September 11, 2023 Advertising Health Services
Corporate & Commercial Health & Aged Care
August 28, 2023 Guidelines: Telehealth Consultations With Patients
Insurance & Risk Management Health & Aged Care
July 17, 2023 Section 18: A Solution Looking for a Problem
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
July 07, 2023 Significant Changes to the Obligation to Provide Suitable Employment Ahead
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
June 09, 2022 Return to Work SA’s Summer of Discontent May Soon Be Over
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
May 11, 2022 Health Sector: Preparing for the End of State-Imposed COVID-19 Vaccination Mandates
Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Health & Aged Care
March 25, 2022 SA Labor to Apply Criminal Law to Workplaces Under its Industrial Relations Policy
Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Agribusiness Defence + 7
March 04, 2022 Why We Should Avoid the Use of the Word “Mandate” When Communicating Vaccination Requirements to Workers and the Wider Community
Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Health & Aged Care Agribusiness + 3
February 01, 2022 The Cost of Workers Compensation in an Ageing Workforce
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
January 14, 2022 Learning to Live With COVID-19 - The Trolley Dilemma in Our Economy
Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Workers Compensation & Self Insurance Agribusiness + 3
December 16, 2021 Summerfield, Opioids and Rising Workers Compensation Premiums – What’s the Connection?
Workers Compensation & Self Insurance
December 09, 2021 Aged Care: Staying Ahead of the Curve
Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety Health & Aged Care