Although most people over 65 will not suffer cognitive impairment, for a large minority, dementia and other age-related conditions will enter their lives at some stage.

According to statistics gathered by the National Centre for Social & Economic Modelling, currently, 250 people are diagnosed with dementia every day, and this is likely to increase to 318 people per day by 2025. Among Australians aged 65 and over, almost 1 in 10 has dementia, and among those aged 85 and over, 3 in 10 have dementia.

The term dementia is an umbrella term used to refer to a collection of symptoms which are caused by disorders affecting the brain. Dementia affects thinking, memory, behaviour and the ability to perform everyday tasks. Although most people with dementia tend to be in the older age bracket, it is not a normal part of ageing but rather a manifestation of some underlying disease.

Some of the underlying diseases are:

  • Alzheimer’s Disease;
  • Vascular Dementia;
  • Parkinson’s Disease; and
  • Fronto-temporal lobe degeneration.

In any discussion of capacity or its loss, it is important to understand that:

  • because a person has been assessed as having dementia, this does not mean that they cannot make a decision about a particular issue. Mental capacity has to be assessed in the context of a particular transaction;
  • at law, a medical diagnosis or absence of diagnosis will not determine whether a person is considered to have the capacity to make decisions; and
  • a medical diagnosis is useful evidence, but it is for a Court or Tribunal of competent jurisdiction to make declarations of capacity or incapacity, as the case may be.

From a legal perspective, mental incapacity is a more far-reaching life event than death. It could be considered to be a Clayton’s death – the death you have when you don’t have a death because life continues after this “death”. The complexity of incapacity is illustrated by the fact that a person’s death instrument, their Will, is a direction for their executor to transmit their assets to beneficiaries. The Will is therefore prescriptive in this transfer of assets and normally does not require decision making on behalf of the executor in that transfer. By comparison, a person’s incapacity instrument, their Enduring Power of Attorney, is not prescriptive, but the delegation of discretion to someone else, namely their attorney. This discretion is exercised during the life of a mentally incapable person and will impact on the ultimate death of that person and the disposition of that person’s wealth.

The discretion is only controlled by three factors, as follows:

  1. fiduciary duties;
  2. statutory restrictions; and
  3. the terms of the Enduring Power of Attorney instrument.

The first two controls are of limited impact when it comes to the ambit of the attorney’s discretion and the ability of an EPA to re-engineering estates during the life of the donor as a consequence of the donor’s death. It is common for the third control to be overlooked or disregarded in the drafting of an Enduring Power of Attorney. The consequence of this is that the potential for abuse of the power by an attorney is enhanced in the wrong hands. The rise in the number of cases coming before the Courts on this issue is demonstrative of the problem. It is also probable that the vast number of attorney maladministration, if not fraud, goes undetected.

It is to be hoped that in most cases, an attorney will do the right thing. However, because it is an instrument that gives a third party the right to control your financial affairs and therefore deal in, manipulate, enhance or damage your wealth assets, care should be taken in deciding who to appoint and what directions are to be given to that person in the care of your financial affairs. After all, in what other situation would we give a third party an untrammelled discretion to manage your financial affairs?

This communication provides general information which is current as at the time of production. The information contained in this communication does not constitute advice and should not be relied upon as such. Professional advice should be sought prior to any action being taken in reliance on any of the information. Should you wish to discuss any matter raised in this article, or what it means for you, your business or your clients' businesses, please feel free to contact us.

For more information, please contact...

Mark Minarelli

View Profile →

Related Articles

View All News
June 19, 2024 Navigating New Relationships After Loss: Understanding Legal and Financial Implications
Wills & Estate Planning
April 18, 2024 2025 Edition of Best Lawyers: Celebrating Our Leaders and a Rising Star
Firm News Corporate & Commercial Employment, Workplace Relations & Safety + 6
April 27, 2020 COVID-19: Business Succession Planning
Wills & Estate Planning
April 10, 2020 Modern Issues in Business Succession Planning
Wills & Estate Planning
April 10, 2020 The Issue of Capacity
Wills & Estate Planning
June 21, 2019 Succession Planning
Tax Wills & Estate Planning
November 09, 2018 “The Thorn Birds Between Two Roses”: Conflicting Wills
Wills & Estate Planning
November 07, 2018 “As Told by Hassold”: A Tale of Many Wills
Wills & Estate Planning
July 04, 2018 Wills: Greedy v Needy
Dispute Resolution & Insolvency Wills & Estate Planning
June 22, 2018 Powers of Attorney
Wills & Estate Planning
June 22, 2018 Making a Will
Wills & Estate Planning
June 22, 2018 Advance Care Directives
Wills & Estate Planning
March 26, 2018 The Benefits of Incorporating a Testamentary Trust in Your Will
Wills & Estate Planning
March 26, 2018 Wills
Wills & Estate Planning
December 21, 2017 In the Estate of Linda Vera Frencken (Deceased) [2017] SASC 160
Wills & Estate Planning
October 31, 2017 So You’ve Been Appointed as an Executor…….Now What?
Wills & Estate Planning
October 31, 2017 Succession Law: Tiburzi v Butler [2017] SASCFC 89 (28 July 2017)
Dispute Resolution & Insolvency Wills & Estate Planning
December 16, 2016 Inheritance Disputes
Dispute Resolution & Insolvency Wills & Estate Planning
May 26, 2016 Wills for Different Countries
International Business Wills & Estate Planning
May 26, 2016 Aged Care - Estate Planning and Substitute Decision-Making
Health & Aged Care Wills & Estate Planning